Skip to main content

Increased ridership and improved affordability: Transforming public transport subsidies in developing contexts

Targeted travel vouchers increase ridership and reduce the burden of transport costs.

Transportation
Affordability
Public policy

Guzman, L. A., Gómez Cardona, S., & Ochoa, J. L. (2024). Increased ridership and improved affordability: Transforming public transport subsidies in developing contexts. Research in Transportation Economics, 108, Article 101492. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.retrec.2024.101492

Authors
Affiliations

Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, SUR, Universidad de los Andes

Maastricht University

Department of Economics, Brown University

Published

November 2024

Doi

Abstract

Short summary of the published abstract. A randomized field experiment with 1,607 frequent public transport users in Bogotá tests vouchers loaded onto travel cards for four months. Vouchers increase ridership, particularly on weekdays and at peak hours, and reduce the burden of public transport expenditures. The study evaluates voucher delivery as an alternative way to provide demand-side subsidies.

Empirical strategy

The experiment randomly offered monthly vouchers of COP 28,000 (A) or COP 21,000 (B), alongside a control group. Administrative travel-card records measure boardings before, during, and after the intervention. Person and week fixed effects absorb stable individual differences and common shocks. The study reports both intention-to-treat (ITT) estimates and effects among voucher activators (ATT), using assignment as an instrument for activation. Affordability is measured using SITP spending relative to income; this index excludes other transport modes.

Main equation

Equation (1), written with the two voucher arms explicitly, is:

\[ Y_{it}=\gamma_i+\lambda_t+ \sum_{g\in\{A,B\}}\left(\beta_g T^g_{it}+\tau_g P^g_{it}\right)+\epsilon_{it}. \]

\(Y_{it}\) is boardings, \(T^g_{it}\) identifies assignment to arm \(g\) during the intervention, and \(P^g_{it}\) identifies its post-intervention period. \(\beta_g\) is the ITT effect; standard errors are clustered by participant.

Selected results

Ridership

Table 1: Percentage changes relative to control-group boardings, selected from Table 2. All-day and weekday effects are significant at \(p<0.01\); weekend effects are not statistically significant. ITT includes everyone offered vouchers; ATT adjusts for activation.
Voucher group ITT: all days ATT: all days ATT: weekdays ATT: weekends
A: COP 28,000 7.22% 8.73% 9.58% 4.13%
B: COP 21,000 6.50% 8.04% 8.98% 4.15%

Affordability

Table 2: SITP affordability index, reproduced from Table 6. Lower values mean a smaller income burden. Both treatment-control differences during the intervention are significant at \(p<0.01\). These are group-period indices, not regression treatment effects.
Group Before During After
Control 19.1% 20.5% 23.6%
A: COP 28,000 20.5% 16.3% 24.3%
B: COP 21,000 21.2% 18.0% 26.2%
  • Usage: activators make about 8–9% more trips; gains concentrate on weekdays and peak periods.
  • Affordability: the burden falls during voucher delivery, with estimated monthly savings of about USD 4.10.
  • Persistence: post-treatment ridership differences are not statistically significant. The evidence concerns frequent users in this experiment rather than a citywide rollout.

Citation

Add to Zotero

@article{GuzmanGomezCardonaOchoa:2024,
    title = {Increased ridership and improved affordability: Transforming public transport subsidies in developing contexts},
    author = {Guzman, Luis A. and Gómez Cardona, Santiago and Ochoa, Jorge Luis},
    doi = {10.1016/j.retrec.2024.101492},
    journal = {Research in Transportation Economics},
    year = {2024},
    volume = {108},
    pages = {101492}
}