Skip to main content

The welfare effects of subsidies: A case study of public transport

Measuring the welfare gains from public transport subsidies through travel choices.

Development economics
Urban economics
Transport
Welfare
Public policy

Ochoa Rincón, J. L. (2023). The welfare effects of subsidies: A case study of public transport [Working paper; English version]. Spanish version: Modelo de elección de modos de transporte: Evidencia de un experimento social controlado (Documento CEDE No. 30). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4575115

Author
Affiliation

Department of Economics, Brown University

Draft updated

November 2023

Abstract

Short summary of the English working paper. Experimental variation in transport subsidies in Bogotá identifies a discrete choice model of travel demand. The model estimates welfare gains as consumer surplus: an average monthly increase of COP 48,085 (USD 12.84), or 3.1% of mean household income. Gains are much larger for non-work trips than for commuting, with differences linked to travel times and schedule flexibility.

Empirical strategy

The Bogotá experiment randomly offered monthly travel-card subsidies of COP 28,000 or COP 21,000, alongside a control group. Baseline and weekly mobility diaries record travel modes, costs, and times. A mixed logit model recovers individual preferences and model-implied consumer surplus. A two-stage difference-in-differences estimator addresses staggered subsidy use when estimating welfare changes. Separate fixed-effects and event-study specifications estimate travel-time responses.

These estimates combine experimental assignment with structural assumptions; results should not be read as general-equilibrium effects of a citywide policy.

Main equation

The random-utility model in Equation (2) is:

\[ U_{ijt}=\theta_i\,\mathrm{Price}_{jt} +\beta_i\,\mathrm{TravelTime}_{ijt} +\tau\,\mathrm{Treatment}_i +\Omega'X_{ijt}+\varepsilon_{ijt}. \]

Price and time coefficients vary across individuals. \(X_{ijt}\) captures observed individual and alternative attributes. The estimated utilities generate a log-sum consumer-surplus measure, expressed in monetary units.

Selected results

Monthly welfare gains

Table 1: Monthly consumer-surplus gains in COP. Selected estimates from Table 3, Panel B (mixed logit with controls). The pooled estimate has a bootstrap 95% confidence interval of [42,777, 53,392]. The estimates are effects among treated users, using the paper’s two-stage procedure.
Group All participants Work trips Other trips
Pooled 48,085 20,951 100,096
A: COP 28,000 58,336 29,637 115,295
B: COP 21,000 38,121 12,594 84,149

Travel-time reductions

Table 2: Selected controlled estimates from Table 4, columns (2) and (4). The pooled and arm-specific estimates come from separate specifications. Both include participant and survey fixed effects; standard errors are clustered by participant and survey.
Group Change in minutes Standard error
Pooled -10.06 3.686
A: COP 28,000 -18.66 7.425
B: COP 21,000 -1.605 4.283
  • Welfare: the larger subsidy raises monthly consumer surplus by about 3.8% of mean household income; the smaller subsidy raises it by about 2.5%.
  • Trip purpose: non-work gains are almost five times work-trip gains, consistent with the role of congestion and less flexible commuting schedules.
  • Time: the pooled reduction is about ten minutes per trip. The larger subsidy drives the decline; the smaller subsidy’s estimate is not statistically significant.

Citation

The English draft is dated November 10, 2023. The linked Spanish CEDE/SSRN version is dated September 14, 2023; the results summarized above follow the English draft.

English working paper

@unpublished{OchoaRincon:2023Welfare,
    title = {The welfare effects of subsidies: A case study of public transport},
    author = {Ochoa Rincón, Jorge Luis},
    year = {2023},
    month = nov,
    note = {English working paper, November 10, 2023},
    url = {https://jorgeluis8ar.github.io/files/WP-Welfare-Effects-Subsidies-Case-Study-Public-Transport.pdf}
}

Spanish CEDE version

Add to Zotero

@techreport{OchoaRincon:2023CEDE,
    title = {Modelo de elección de modos de transporte: Evidencia de un experimento social controlado},
    author = {Ochoa Rincón, Jorge Luis},
    doi = {10.2139/ssrn.4575115},
    institution = {Universidad de los Andes},
    type = {Documento CEDE},
    number = {30},
    year = {2023},
    month = sep,
    url = {https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4575115}
}